Review of Murder in the First (1995) by Sol H — 10 Aug 2011

Yet another example of why films shouldn't be based on real stories. I've always felt that in order to turn true events into a well structured and compelling narrative, you have to completely make stuff up and change the facts to the point that you might as well be writing an original screeplay. This film understands that you shouldn't be hung up on the truth and should just change facts to fit the story, but what it doesn't understand is the ethical implications of doing such a thing. This film takes a convicted murderer who was, by all accounts I can find, a horrible human being and turns him into a one-dimensional victim of circumstances who we're supposed to feel sorry for and cheer on. It means that said murderer has now been glorified and will be remembered through history as something of a martyr.

The cast is a real all-star affair though, which gives it a touch of credibility although Kevin Bacon's performance, which seems to be the central selling point of it all, is completely cartoonish and feels laughable. It was difficult for me to watch because I love Kevin Bacon.

Still, the film is reasonably entertaining. Functional, but with lots of emotional manipulation and and irresponsible disregard for historical accuracy. If someone tells you this is one of those amazing films nobody is has ever seen -it isn't.

6/10.